McDonald’s sponsored the annual conference of the California branch of the nutritionists’ professional organization. Kiera Butler

Our national nutrition experts are in bed with Junk Food Corporations. And we wonder why we’re fat.

One recent Friday afternoon, in a Mariott Hotel ballroom in Pomona, California, I watched two women skeptically evaluate their McDonald’s lunches. One peered into a plastic bowl containing a salad of lettuce, bacon, chicken, cheese, and ranch dressing. The other arranged two chocolate chip cookies and a yogurt parfait on a napkin. “Eww,” she said, gingerly stirring the layers of yogurt and pink strawberry goop. The woman with the salad nodded in agreement, poking at a wan chicken strip with her plastic fork.

When I asked how they were liking their lunches, both women grimaced and assured me that they “never” go to McDonald’s. So why were they eating it today? Well, they didn’t really have a choice. The women were registered dietitians halfway through day two of the annual conference of the California Dietetic Association (CDA). They were hoping to rack up some of the continuing education credits they needed to maintain their certification. McDonald’s, the conference’s featured sponsor, was the sole provider of lunch. “I guess it’s good to know that they have healthier options now,” said the woman with the salad.

Cheerful reps at the Hershey’s booth passed out miniature cartons of chocolate and strawberry milk.

As I wandered the exhibition hall, I saw that McDonald’s wasn’t the only food company giving away freebies. Cheerful reps at the Hershey’s booth passed out miniature cartons of chocolate and strawberry milk. Butter Buds offered packets of fake butter crystals. The California Beef Council guy gave me a pamphlet on how to by eating steak. Amy’s Naturals had microwave brownies. The night before, Sizzler, California Pizza Kitchen, Boston Market, and other chain restaurants had hosted a free evening buffet for conference-goers: “Local Restaurant Samplings for Your Pleasure.”

And that wasn’t all. The sessions—the real meat and potatoes of the conference—had food industry sponsors as well. The Wheat Council hosted a presentation about how gluten intolerance was just a fad, not a real medical problem. The International Food Information Council—whose supporters include Coca-Cola, Hershey, Yum Brands, Kraft, and McDonald’s—presented a discussion in which the panelists assured audience members that genetically modified foods were safe and environmentally sustainable. In “Bringing Affordable Healthier Food to Communities,” Walmart spokespeople sang the praises of (what else?) Walmart.


McDonald’s catered lunch at the conference. Kiera Butler

After lunch, I attended “Sweeteners in Schools: Keeping Science First in a Controversial Discussion.” Sponsored by the Corn Refiners Association, whose members produce and sell high-fructose corn syrup, it included a panel composed of three of the trade group’s representatives. The panelists bemoaned some schools’ decision to remove chocolate milk from their cafeteria menus. Later, one panelist said that she’d been dismayed to learn that some schools had banned sugary treats from classroom Valentine’s Day parties, which “could be a teachable moment for kids about moderation.” The moderator nodded in agreement, and added, “The bottom line is that all sugars contain the same calories, so you can’t say that there is one ingredient causing the obesity crisis.” The claim was presented as , despite mounting scientific evidence that high-fructose corn syrup prompts more than other sugars.

The School Nutrition Association has asked Congress to lift the rule that students must take fruits and vegetables on the lunch line.

Later, I asked conference spokeswoman Pat Smith whether she thought it was fair to present such a one-sided discussion. She claimed that the sponsors did not influence any of the content in the program. “We like to think that our dietitians have a thought process and that we are presenting them with what is out there,” she said. “They need to make their own decisions on what they have listened to and apply that to their client base.”

“But it’s hard to make a decision if you’re only hearing one side of the story,” I countered.

She told me that she hadn’t known beforehand that the Corn Refiners panel would be composed entirely of its own representatives. And yet, when I asked her how the panel was chosen, she explained that it was approved by a committee. She also confirmed that the Corn Refiners had paid for the panel, but she declined to say how much. (She had previously declined me press credentials for the conference, explaining that the CDA would have its own journalists covering the event.)

With 75,000 members, the CDA’s parent organization, the national Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics (AND), is the world’s largest professional association for nutritionists and dietitians. It accredits undergraduate and graduate programs in nutrition science and awards credentials to dietitian degree candidates who pass its exam. In Washington, its lobbying arm is active on issues including childhood obesity, Medicare, and the farm bill.

It also has strong ties to the food industry. In 2013, Michele Simon, a public health lawyer and food politics blogger, launched an investigation (PDF) into the academy’s sponsorship policies. Simon found that its corporate support has increased dramatically over the past decade: In 2001, the academy listed just 10 sponsors. By 2011, there were 38, including Coca-Cola, PepsiCo, Nestlé, National Cattlemen’s Beef Association, Mars, and many others. Corporate contributions are its largest source of income, generating nearly 40 percent of its total revenue.

Simon also learned that in 2012, Nestlé paid $47,200 for its 2,500-square-foot display in the exhibition hall at the annual AND conference, and PepsiCo paid $38,000 for 1,600 square feet. The academy’s position papers, she noted, state that its sponsors do not influence its positions on controversial issues. And yet it often takes a pro-industry stance. When New York City was considering a ban on sales of oversized sodas, for example, the academy opposed it.

“No wonder Americans are overweight and diabetic. The gatekeepers for our information about food are getting their information from junk-food companies.”

AND is not the only powerful nutritionists group with strong corporate ties. The sponsors of the School Nutrition Association‘s 2013 annual conference included PepsiCo, Domino’s Pizza, and Sara Lee. SNA made headlines recently when it asked Congress to lift the rule that students must take fruits and vegetables on the lunch line, and to ease the rules around sodium and whole grains.

Marion Nestle, a New York University nutritionist, wrote about nutritionists and corporate sponsorships in her 2007 book, Food Politics: How the Food Industry Influences Nutrition and Health. “I worry a lot about food industry co-optation of my profession,” she wrote to me in an email. “Food companies are smart. They know that if they can make friends and help inform dietitians and nutritionists that the people they are supporting or helping will be reluctant to suggest eating less of their products.”

Andy Bellatti, a dietitian and member of AND, recalls his shock the first time he attended the organization’s national conference, in 2008. “I could get continuing education credits for literally sitting in a room and listening to Frito-Lay tell me that Sun Chips are a good way to meet my fiber needs,” he says. “I thought, ‘No wonder Americans are overweight and diabetic. The gatekeepers for our information about food are getting their information from junk-food companies.'”

Bellatti took photos of the displays in the exhibition hall and posted them on his blog. The post started a conversation among academy members, many of whom were outraged when they learned about the sponsorships. They worried that if word got out that dietitians’ professional organization had been bought out by food corporations, the profession would lose credibility. So Bellatti and several other members founded Dietitians for Professional Integrity, consisting of academy members who want to the sponsorship policies. They lobbied the leadership, but nothing changed—except for the rules about photography at the annual conference. The following year, when Bellatti took out his camera in the exhibition hall, he was told that photographs were prohibited.

Simon, the author of the 2013 report, found in a survey of AND members that four-fifths believed “sponsorship implies Academy endorsement of that company.” Just as many said that they thought members should have a say in selecting the sponsors, and most said that they would be willing to pay higher dues in order to avoid having so many corporations represented at the annual conference.

I asked AND spokesman Tom Ryan whether the academy has any plans to review its rules for food industry sponsors. He referred me to the academy’s corporate sponsorship website, which contains no suggestion of forthcoming changes. When I pressed him on it, Ryan replied, “I am not going to respond to that question.”

At the CDA conference I attended, most of the dietitians I talked to said that they did not realize the sessions were sponsored by companies. “I hope they’re telling us the real science,” said one graduate student attendee.

At the McDonald’s booth, company spokespeople told conference attendees about McDonald’s healthy menu options. Kiera Butler

Toward the end of the day, I spoke to a 65-year-old retired dietitian from Orange County. She told me she’d been attending CDA’s annual conferences for 30 years. Shaking her head, she said that she didn’t approve of the trend of junk-food sponsors. “I guess they need the money, but this is pathetic,” she said, rolling her eyes. She found the McDonald’s lunch particularly deplorable. “A dietitian you’d expect to be principled,” she said. “But here I feel like we’re sleeping with the enemy.”


Find a Nutritionist

What Nutritionists Eat At Fast-Food Restaurants –

Is there such a thing as healthy fast food? To find out, we asked nutritionists who plan menus for fast food chain restaurants what they order when they eat there. Get their suggestions for the healthiest fast food.

Dieticians And Nutritionists Answer Questions Video

Difference Between Dietitian and Nutritionist

... ... 000 1 100 2,500-square-foot display 65-year-old retired dietitian Academy Academy endorsement academy members act Affordable Healthier Food afternoon agreement alan watts Americans andy bellatti annual conference annual conferences answer association audience audience members author awards credentials bacon ban bed Beef Association blog book booth Boston Market Butter Buds C. cafeteria menus California California Beef Council California branch California Pizza Kitchen calories CDA conference center certification chain restaurants Chang. change changed—except Changes Cheerful reps cheese chicken childhood obesity chocolate chip cookies chocolate milk choice city classroom Valentine client base Coca-Cola Committee Communities companies company company spokespeople conference attendees conference spokeswoman Pat conference-goers conference—had food industry Congress content Controversial Discussion controversial issues cookies Corn Refiners corn refiners association Corn Refiners panel corn syrup Corporate contributions corporate sponsorship website corporate sponsorships corporate support Corporations Council Council—whose supporters cover credentials credibility credit credits D.C. decade decision decisions degree diabetic Dietetics Dieticians dietitian degree candidates dietitians difference discussion displays Ease eating education education credits email end enemy. environment event Eww example exhibition hall experts eyes fact fad fake fake butter crystals farm fast food chain Fast-Food Restaurants featured sponsor Feel feet fiber fiber needs fine. food Food Companies food company food corporations food industry food industry co-optation food industry sponsors food politics blogger Foods form forthcoming changes four-fifths free evening buffet freebies friends fructose corn syrup fruits gatekeepers genetically modified food genetically modified foods gluten intolerance good way graduate programs graduate student graduate student attendee grains group halfway head headlines health Healthier healthier options healthiest fast food Healthy healthy menu options help Hershey high fructose corn syrup higher dues hope How To image industry influence information ingredient International Food Information international food information council investigation junk junk food Junk Food Corporations junk-food companies junk-food sponsors kids Kiera Butler Kraft largest source law layers leadership Learn lettuce line list lobbying arm Local Restaurant Samplings Lose Weight lunch line lunches M.D. Mar. Marion Nestle Mariott Hotel ballroom Market McDonald meat member members Michele Simon microwave brownies miniature cartons moderation moderator moment Moment | Healing money napkin National Academy National Cattlemen national cattlemen's beef association national nutrition experts Naturals need needs Nestlé new york new york city night note nutrition nutrition science nutritionist Nutritionists Answer Questions Nutritionists Eat obesity crisis one-sided discussion options Orange County order oversized sodas overweight packets page pamphlet panelist panelists papers parent organization parties past past decade PDF people PepsiCo percent photo photographs photography photos pink strawberry goop Pizza plan plans plastic bowl plastic fork policies Politics Pomona position papers post potatoes powerful nutritionists group praises present presentation press credentials pro-industry stance problem process product PRODUCTS Professional Integrity professional organization program programs public Public Health public health lawyer question questions quote R. ranch dressing real medical problem real science recent Friday afternoon report representatives restaurant revenue review right room rule rules S.C. Safe salad sales Sales | Max Sara Lee school School Nutrition Association schools science Scientific scientific evidence sessions—the real meat site Sizzler Smith SNA sole provider source spokesman Tom Ryan sponsorship policies square feet start state steak story strawberry milk strong corporate ties strong ties students sugars sugary sugary treats suggestion suggestions Sun Sun Chips support survey Sweeteners teachable moment them. thing thought time total revenue trade trade group try type university vegetables video Video Difference Walmart spokespeople wan chicken strip want Washington way website weight weight gain Wheat Council woman women word world worry yogurt parfait York University nutritionist Yum Brands

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.